Performance Ratings are Failing: What you should do instead

A decade or so ago, performance management reviews were the fashionable trend in the HR spectrum. Business leaders revered performance ratings, swore by them, and dared to put them on a pedestal. But the annual performance ratings have since seen a downward trajectory. So, what went wrong, and is removing performance ratings really the way to go?

A decade or so ago, performance management reviews were the fashionable trend in the HR spectrum. Business leaders revered performance ratings, swore by them, and dared to put them on a pedestal. But the annual performance ratings have since seen a downward trajectory. 

So, what went wrong, and is removing performance ratings really the way to go?

The Numbers Behind the Spectacular Fall of Performance Ratings

Why are so many employees unhappy after their performance ratings? Why do HR leaders often dread conducting reviews? You’d think this bottleneck would have been cleared by now, judging from the hundreds of blogs and white papers addressing the importance of performance management. And yet:

  • Only 18% of HR leaders agree on the effectiveness of performance management at achieving its primary objective. (2019 Gartner Performance Management Benchmarking Survey)
  • A whopping 81% of HR leaders would make changes to their current approach to performance management. (Gartner)
  • 15% of HR managers plan on removing performance ratings in the near future, while 6% have already removed them. 28% of the surveyed group have no plans to remove ratings but would consider. (CEB 2016 Agenda Poll).

So, why are we in this quandary? The answer is simple, really: HR leaders have been focusing on the wrong aspects of performance management. 

Rethinking Performance Ratings: What to Include and What to Shred Out

Problem 1: The Annual, Episodic Review

Twelve months is a long, long time. Can you remember what you tweeted about this time last year? Even the best HR leaders would struggle to remember tasks assigned, and work completed a year ago. As such, the annual performance ratings are toothless at best and demotivating at worse.

Thing is, leaders loathe the workload involved in having to remember a year’s worth of effort for each employee. Workers also get frustrated when they realize their past achievements have been swept under the rug or forgotten entirely.

Solution: Provide Ongoing, Not Episodic, Performance Review

According to the CEB 2012 High Performance Survey, continuous feedback can have a respectable 12% impact on employee performance. A yearly review simply doesn’t cut it. Instead, focus on holding a quarterly or mid-year review. Not only does this break up the pressure of the episodic review, but it also allows you to adjust expectations on employees based on past performance or organizational changes.

Problem 2: Reducing "Effort" in Performance Management

When organizations first paddled the uncharted waters of performance management, the primary goal was to assess employee performance. 

Today, organizations rely on PM systems to drive employee performance, engagement, and development, as well as inform compensation, promotion, and succession planning decisions. These increasing demands on PM mean that HR leaders end up putting too much effort into understanding performance management complaints. It’s a tight rope to walk on.

By “too much effort”, we mean:

  • Cumbersome technology
  • Overly complex 
  • Asking too much of managers and employees
  • Too much time required
  • Requires extensive energy
  • Not user-friendly

While reducing effort might seem like the outright fix to this stalemate, it’s often not the case.

Solution: Focus on Increasing Utility, Not Decreasing Time and Effort

Newsflash: Reducing “effort” in performance management reduces workforce performance by up to 16.6%.  

Assuming that your PM boat is already rocking, decreasing time and effort would send it underwater. Focusing on utility would be a better idea. No matter how much time and effort you spend on performance management, your employees only perceive PM to be worth it when it has high utility. 

Yes, eliminating performance ratings is a prudent move. But even then, the existing review should be modeled to ensure it’s highly useful and utility-oriented. As such, it should be:

  • Tailored for individuals, not collaboration
  • Accurate and fair
  • Highly engaging and motivating
  • Perfectly aligned with business needs
  • Provide deep insight into business priorities
  • Relevant to work

That’s it. Simple. Then go ahead and scrap the final rating. A good performance management review should be based around
solid coaching and continuous improvement, not placing someone into a number box. 

Problem 3: Your Managers Are Not Well Coached

You can have the best PM processes and systems in the world, but if your managers have no clue about how to make the most of a performance review, then you’re doomed. Don’t assume that your HR managers know how to glean actionable insights from a review or award ratings objectively. Heck, some are not even capable of conducting multiple feedback sessions in a short space of time.

Just picture a HR manager indicating “Fairly Good” against every question about each of your employees’ performance. It’ll help no one.

Solution: Coach and Support Your HR Managers

The CEB 2014 Enterprise Contribution Workforce Survey reveals that making performance reviews forward-looking can have a 13% impact on performance. That’s a good statistic to ride on.

So, how do you make your reviews forward-looking and not backward-looking? Easy—embrace leadership coaching. Effective coaching gives HR managers the platform to discuss, assess, and refine their PM approaches. It acts as a sounding board that helps them know how prepared they’re for leadership. More importantly, it helps them realize that removing performance ratings is only half the battle. The other half, as a cutting-edge leadership development program would show, is tailored around handling poor performers and how to extract even more from their best performers.

A Few Final Words

There’s no doubt about it. Traditional performance ratings are ineffective at properly measuring and retaining talent. Don’t wait to see the day when your best performers will walk out the door simply because the ratings were too harsh, too shallow, or otherwise blurry. Give them a reason to stay. Master the art of conducting honest, constructive, and holistic reviews. And it all starts with getting the right kind of leadership coaching.

At Sounding Board, we’re passionate about up-leveling HR and business leaders’ mindsets and practices through robust coaching solutions. Our scientifically designed Coaching Enablement Platform and a curated network of leadership coaches are on hand to help you take the next step in your career. Request a demo or contact us today to learn more.

Join Our Newsletter!

Newsletter Signup

Share on linkedin
Share on twitter
Share on facebook

Request A Demo

We Develop The World's Most Impactful Leaders

From leading remote workforces, building productive teams, to improving diversity, equity, and inclusion, Sounding Board has virtual and scalable enterprise solutions that are urgently required to adapt to rapidly changing workplace environments.

Demo Request

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Play Video
Play Video
Play Video

Piyush Gupta

VP of Product and Technology
Piyush Gupta is VP of Product and Technology at Sounding Board and champions the voice of customers and users with deep empathy. Piyush envisions Sounding Board to be the first window of coaching experience for professionals and leaders worldwide. His approach is deeply rooted in proven scientific research, modeling human behaviors, and data-informed insights to deliver mindset shifts and desired business outcomes for organizations at scale. He believes that a world-class UX is key to drive simplicity that will lead to millions of professionals to access coaching for their development. Piyush co-invented the world’s first ‘landmark intelligent driving directions’ technology that led Google to redesign their routing algorithms for the Asian markets. For the next decade, he led two disruptive FinTech companies to the market leadership positions and delivered two award-winning products that serve more than 70 million users worldwide. His teams filed 20+ patents while he himself authored three patents. He is an active startup investor and advises selected AI-driven startups on business and product strategy. He is the recipient of the World Summit Award, one of the most prestigious international honors for product innovators. In addition, he is a James Swartz fellow, the most prestigious fellowship at Carnegie Mellon University funded by the founder of the iconic venture firm, Accel Partners. Piyush holds an MS in Software Management from Carnegie Mellon University.

Tommy Perkins


Tommy is at his best helping clients think through complex challenges in order to create a positive impact on their organizations. He thrives when interacting with others whether helping his team succeed or working with clients to build long-term partnerships. He has extensive experience consulting with organizations on driving their employee experience, guiding organizations through change, and working to ensure organizations are moving the needle when it comes to their results.

Most recently, Tommy was a Client Services Leader overseeing some of GP’s most prized accounts on a global level. His responsibilities included overall client growth strategy, retention, and satisfaction. He represented all of GP Strategies’ major business lines including leadership, coaching, and engagement, digital transformation, outsourced services, and technology implementation solutions.

Before GP Strategies, Tommy spent several years with TTEC Digital (formerly rogenSI) where he led the sales team,  eventually becoming the regional Learning & Performance practice leader for North America. While managing the P&L and sales team he also led the largest global relationship for the firm (Deloitte Globally). During his time at TTEC, he focused on delivering blended learning solutions that incorporate technology and hands-on training. Before TTEC Digital, he spent several years dedicated to strength-based leadership disrupting the business landscape regarding performance management and employee engagement with thought leader Marcus Buckingham at The Marcus Buckingham Company / TMBC (now ADP).

Tommy has had the privilege of working with some of the most well-known global brands in professional services, retail, technology, and healthcare including Deloitte, Facebook, Microsoft, Bank of America, Novartis, Gap Inc., lululemon, and Intel. Several projects he led for Deloitte were Global GNPS, New Partner Pivot, NextGen Partner Program Deloitte China, Present to Win, the RPM project on performance management, and Unconscious Bias.

Tommy holds a BS in Health Sciences from Texas A&M University, and an MBA from Universidad del CEMA.

Learn How to Build Agile and Productive Leaders Now!

From leading remote workforces, building productive teams, to improving diversity, equity, and inclusion, Sounding Board has virtual and scalable enterprise solutions that are urgently required to adapt to rapidly changing workplace environments.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

We respect your privacy! Your information will not be shared

Join our coaching team

Our expert coaches combine top notch coaching, business acumen and organizational savvy to truly become your leadership “Sounding Board”. Sounding Board coaches are all industry certified and strongly vetted going through a 3 step qualification process and receiving ongoing supervision and development.

Lori Mazan

Co-Founder & CCO Sounding Board, Inc.
Lori Mazan is the Co-Founder and Chief Coaching Officer of Sounding Board, the preeminent global leadership development enterprise platform changing the face of leadership development through innovative technology for leaders at all levels of an organization. Lori is a seasoned executive coach who has guided hundreds of corporate executives through 1:1 coaching focused on business outcomes and developing critical leadership skills. Client companies advanced by Lori’s expertise include Fortune titans such as Chevron and Sprint as well as high growth and public companies like Intellikine, and Tapjoy, plus 10XGenomics, which became a public company in 2019 while top executives worked with Lori and the Sounding Board team.
Lori has spent the last 25 years coaching C-Suite executives to leadership excellence. Many of those public and private company CEO’s expressed that they would have liked this caliber of coaching earlier in their careers. Inspired by these experiences, Lori joined with Christine to launch Sounding Board as a feedback-driven, cloud-based leadership coaching platform that could maintain best-in-class leadership coaching while lowering costs to make it affordable and scalable for leaders at every level of their careers.
Before founding Sounding Board, Lori received her Masters’ in Adult Educational Psychology/Counseling from the University of San Francisco and a Bachelors’ in Psychology from the University of Virginia. Lori is an educator and has spent over 10 years as a professor of social psychology and group dynamics while acting as the interim Dean of Students at Holy Names University, She is certified by the industry’s gold standard, the Coaches Training Institute, and is a founding member of the Genentech Preferred Network of Coaches. Sounding Board is one of <3% of sole female founded startups receiving venture funding. In 2019 Sounding Board was selected as 1 of 7 startups (out of 100+ applicants) as part of SAP’s HR tech cohort, a group that represents the rising stars of the next-gen HR ecosystem.

Christine Tao

Co-Founder & CEO Sounding Board, Inc.
Christine Tao is the co-founder & CEO at Sounding Board, a Silicon Valley startup redefining how organizations are developing their leaders. Her extraordinarily rapid career growth to executive management in the media, mobile and tech sectors of Silicon Valley became her inspiration for founding Sounding Board. As she began to manage larger teams and be responsible for growing revenues, it became clear that she needed a “sounding board” to coach her on the development of her leadership skills. That’s where her Sounding Board co-founder, Lori Mazan came on the scene. A seasoned executive coach focused on leadership development, Lori coached Christine on real-world leadership skills that had a direct impact on business outcomes. Based on her positive and impactful experience with leadership development, Christine was driven to make leadership development coaching accessible to people at all levels of the organization.
Christine advises several startups, is a budding angel investor and is also a Tory Burch Foundation Fellow, a foundation dedicated to investing in the success and sustainability of women entrepreneurs.
Prior to co-founding Sounding Board, Christine was a Senior Vice President of Developer Relations at Tapjoy, a venture-backed, leading mobile advertising & publishing network. She led the growth of Tapjoy’s publisher advertising business from 0 to over $100 million in revenues in less than 3 years. Prior to that she led e-commerce partnerships and strategy at YouTube. Christine holds an MBA in Marketing & Operations from Wharton and a BA in Business Administration from UC Berkeley.

Want to learn more about how Sounding Board can help your organization?

Simply fill out the form below and we will be in contact soon. If you are interested in becoming a Sounding Board Coach please visit our careers page.

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.